| David Currie |
125 |
| Scott McDonald |
124 |
| Nicky Mohan |
124 |
| John Smith |
124 |
| James Weir |
124 |
| Alfred Common |
124 |
| Bobby Murdoch |
123 |
| Mel Nurse |
123 |
| Brian Phillips |
123 |
| John Marshall |
121 |
| James Thackeray |
121 |
| Hayden Hackney |
120 |
| Gary ONeil |
120 |
| Derek McLean |
120 |
| Frederick Gibson |
120 |
| Steve Bloomer |
120 |
| George Saville |
118 |
| Ray Barnard |
118 |
| William Carr |
118 |
| Adam Johnson |
117 |
| Dave Chadwick |
117 |
| Matt Crooks |
115 |
| Darren Wood |
114 |
| Dimitrios Konstantopoulos |
113 |
| Mickel Beck |
113 |
| Albert Elkes |
113 |
| Robert Pender |
113 |
| Jonathan Woodgate |
112 |
| Darren Randolph |
112 |
| Dave Shearer |
112 |
| William Fox |
112 |
| John Stirling |
112 |
| William Barker |
112 |
| Nicky Bailey |
111 |
| Joseph Desire-Job |
111 |
| Bob Appleby |
111 |
| Doriva |
110 |
| Ashley Fletcher |
109 |
| Jonathan Greening |
109 |
| Archie Stephens |
108 |
| John McKay |
108 |
| John Walker |
108 |
| Riley McGree |
106 |
| Paul Ince |
106 |
| James Watson |
106 |
| Marvin Johnson |
105 |
| Eddie Connachan |
105 |
| George Laking |
105 |
| Kenneth Cameron |
105 |
| Yakubu |
104 |